Brooke has always been pretty. But IMO Peyton got prettier as the seasons progressed.

Brooke and Peyton have always been beutiful! Millie ehhh... she's okay. But Haley, imean she was cute but then she just went to beutiful!

I don't think Peyton has, I think Peyton was prettiest in S1.
Brooke has always been stunning.
Whereas Haley was fairly plain in season 1, but over the seasons has just got more and more beautiful.
Don't really care about Millie. lol.

definitely haley

Haley went from average to stunning!

And Haley.

and Haley. Brooke is pretty, but she hasn't changed throughout the seasons as much as Peyton and Haley have

Peyton has always looked beautiful just different looks throughout the seasons. and Haley has her seasons when she is really beautiful and times when she is not as much but Brooke...season 1 and season 5.....the difference in her beauty...she was pretty in both but season 5 was just beyond just pretty..she looked STUNNING!

peyton was pretty s1 rest of the seasons got ugly, brooke is forever beautiful

and Haley.
To be honest, Brooke is the prettiest but she always looked the same

Either Haley or Peyton. Brooke has always been pretty but Haley and Peyton have become prettier in a maturer sort of way.

Definitely Haley & than Peyton.

Definitaly Haley!Brooke was always pretty,Peyton got worse in my opinion.

Brooke has always been pretty but she also had her bad days. TBH she was pretty average in s1. Her hair was horrible until she straightened her hair in s2. IMO Peyton regressed, she was gorgeous in the earlier seasons and she was just meh in the adult seasons. Idk if it's just me but she got super skinny, her longer orangey hair dragging her down. Haley, on the other hand, went from cute and dorky to gorgeous.

^Agree 100%.

To be honest they all looked better at the beginning and then got worse.

Brooke, Haley & Peyton have always been pretty, attractive ladies, but for me Brooke is always gorgeous, there's never anything plain about her imo. Peyton may not always stand out as much as Brooke, but she didn't go through quite the drastic change that Haley ultimately has!

Haley.. my god, she went from this average, plain jane type, to a little more stand-outish with her S2 look, and then come S3 she just exploded for lack of a better word. Suddenly she's this blond bombshell! And don't get me started on some of the curls she has had...

she started off as cute but now she's gorgeous.
Peyton and Brooke look almost the same.
And Millie was never tht hot.

deffo Hales!

they gave her the name pretty girl for a reason;)