Hard one, but the legs are epic! xD

There's nothing special about Peyton's legs, but not everyone has dimples like hers!

nothing special about them? HAHA! have you seen them? dude. they're amazing! yes, brooke's dimples are adorable, but still; peyton's legs has been pointed out so many times on the show :)

peyton legs are amazing...

I would say the opposite... I don't think there's really anything special about dimples... But Peytons legs make me hate her sometimes lol

Ummm..peytons legs are just skinny..i'm sorry but nothing special.

I've NEVER seen amazing dimples like Brookes<3

Peytons legs aren't just skinny... but they're also really toned and muscular. She has awesome calves. I'd love to have legs like hers!

Sexy legs!

ROFL.

although i love Brooke's dimples, Peytons legs are pretty amazing especially in the later seasons.Season 6 Episode 7, they are great in that episode :) i think a lot of girls would love legs like hers!

they are just legs xD

I love Brooke dimples , they are sooo adorble <3

ughh this is a hard one.
love both so much..but I'll go with Peyton's legs, like Kristine said, they are EPIC <3

But honestly..I would kill to have Brooke's dimples, they're the cutest <3

I'll go with Peyton's legs.

Peyton´s legs are to die for

Peyton's legs? Seriously?
All the characters in the show have legs... LOL! But not everyone has dimples... I just have to agree with the ones that said that the legs are not special.
Although I think that this pick is more like Brooke vs Peyton and not Dimples vs Legs.

They're so cutee <33
But Peyton's legs are pretty sexyy xD

I think Peyton's legs are significant because Lucas sure does love watching and commenting on her legs..which I think is adorable but I think Brooke's dimples are so cute.

As for Team_Brooke....If it was a Brooke vs Peyton pick then I would have picked Peyton...but it's dimples vs legs....and I thought Brooke's were better!

They're so freaking cute :P

Is that even a question?...Brooke's dimples are soooo freaking ADORABLE....xD

Freaking cute!!<3

I gotta go with Brooke! I just have a thing for dimples, and Brooke's dimples are super cute. :) buttt Peyton's legs are epic too.

Sooooooooo cute love it....

Just because they have a role in the show

Well I already have dimples, while they aren't as amazing as Sophia's, they still are cute LOL. I don't think there's anything special with Hil's legs except for they're long and skinny. I'd give anything to have an inch or two added to my height.

i have dimples too but i had to pick this option because i don't see anything special with Peyton's legs, she has no curves at all.

I do love brookes dimples -i dont have dimples & i wish i did, they add to brookes gorgeousness & look so cute :D
Peyton does have great legs though, long & slim!

I've got dimples too so GO BROOKE lol! I like the reference for Peyton's legs!
So I prefer the dimples lol!!

I love both. LOL
And Peyton has gorgeous legs. But i find Brooke's dimples adorables, so i pick her. ;)

I have legs kinda like Peyton's not exactly the same but similar and ofc i like better what i don't have :Brooke's dimples

Ask Lucas :p
I love Peyton's chickeny legs

both really :)