I think all of them were really amazing! :)
It was kinda hard to choose between Jimmy, Brooke and Nathan's scenes, but in the end i have to say Jimmy scene at 3.16. I loved that episode. Jimmy was so great and at some parts almost made me cry.

Jimmy was great at the episode! Amazing actor!

these are all great performances but I think one of the best next to Jimmy and Peyton from 3.16 was Brooke in 3.22. It is really hard to watch that scene along with 3.16 with out crying.

Lets be honest, he was actually THE best actor on the show, and that performance should have won countless awards.

Yay! You took my idea! Thanks, dermer.
Anyways, I think they are all amazing. But, you never really see Haley acting very dramatic and joy/haley were so great this season. You could really feel her pain.
Jimmy was pretty good, too but at times I thought it wasn't very realistic and it was sort of stupid.
Brooke was AMAZING.
So was nathan, oh my god. HEART BREAKERS.

no problem

by far the best acting in oth.. or when Peyton find out Ellie dies:(

when he's talking to Keith...it breaks my heart every time =(

next to Jimmy!!great performances!!!i also was very sad when Brooke cried at 3.22!!felt really sorry for her:(

but so was peytons! that episode, omg, it was hard core.

3.16 was on the best episodes in the entire series all the performances were great but the best one 3.16 had to be jimmy and then Peyton's.

peytons and jimmys (both heartbreaking)...the rest were great as well but that episode was soooooo well acted!

their all really dramatic i can't watch 3.16 without crying but i like 4.09 cause i never seen nathan so dramatic before

"i wanted them to leave me alone..i wanted them to like me..it hurts, it always hurts" amazing acting! gave me chills
and nathan too, he was great!

i didnt hink peytons axting was that good in the shooting one not as good as the others listed i think her acting when she found ellie dead was amazing but i picked this coz when nathan jumps in the river and she was just amazing i really felt for her you could see it in her eyes and everything she was amaizng

how could i forget about haley's great performance? when she screams, omg!!! amazing!

omg i almost cried with that scene i felt soo sorry for lucas

she was soo good.

Sophia Bush's acting in this scene is truly amazing!

aww i changed my option cuz no one picked rachellll!
danneel is AMAZING, stop picking your faves!
also the nathan, peyton 316 & brooke 322 ones were hard to watch!
i always start crying when my faves cry loll

definately.

omg, rip my heart out and throw it in the river with Nathan. Scream and cry with Haley while whats left of my heart crumbles to a million pieces.

Joy did amazing ♥