This was perfect! I cried my eyes out when I heard the song, and everybody was singing along, and then the whole cast at Karen's cafe, it was great <3

I also loved the voiceover in the second part of the ending. Especially the "Make a wish" quote, it's one of my all time fave OTH quotes, I'm glad they repeated it. And highschool Nathan, Haley and Brooke, and Skills and Bevin together? awesome :) and pregnant Millie was adorable. I just don't like the future part because the original kids couldn't play the characters, and they just had to add some new kids.

the kids don't speak, they are in it for like 5 seconds, why weren't they better cast! and what no one had anymore kids in all these years, hit naley have a teenager for christ sake.

It should have ended here this was so perfect. It really didn't need the 5 years or whatever into the future thing, it was perfect just like this. All of them at the cafe together, with their families.
And like @Broody_4_Cherry said, it seems unlikely that none of them had more kids, except Mouth & Millie being pregnant. I would imagine Clay & Quinn having a kid of their own other than Logan, and Brulian to have a girl.

Both!!!

i adored both!

I loved it!

Both, I chose this one cuz this song's been there for 9 years

both were perfect!

both!

I thought both were cheesy. But this one was by far the better of the two. I thought the whole "future" scene was just weird... everything about it felt awkward. :/

Both.

Both

You should have seen me... I started ugly crying right when I heard the song beginning and then when everyone was singing along I was singing too but I was a mess... you know when you cry so much that you don't make a sound? Well, I was like that and at the same time trying to sing along.

I was crying my eyes out and I could not stop mumbling. I don't even know what I was mumbling. My mom even had chills when everyone was singing along with I Don't Wanna Be. I personally think Mark was a genius for doing that.