|
SiriusSeverus said:
!!!.-*SPOILER*-.!!!.-*SPOILER*-.!!! He was a little, miss-guided... (I think these days we'd say he "fell in with the wrong crowd"). He Остаться в живых his only true friend for a stupid mistake, and regretted it for the rest of his life. I believe he had a good streak in him all along... It's only when he realised V ment to kill Lily that he really settled to the good side. Which for me poses two еще (however obsolete) Вопросы - - Had he been placed in Griffindor instead of Slytherin, would he have become a DE? Now, I believe he was something of a follower at school. I think he became a DE because he made Друзья with people who actually WERE bad. Basically, just fell in with whoever would accept him. Had he been in Griff, and stayed Друзья with Lily, she may have brought out the best in him... Probably still fallen in Любовь with James instead, but Sev may well have ended up with even the Marauders as friends! (Not close friends, I don't think, but... Друзья in the way that Dean Thomas is a friend of Harrys, for example). - So he's stayed in Slyth, and all that has happened with Lily as in the book and so on. Had V attacked Neville and his family instead of the Potters, would Sev ever have gone to DD and begged for help, thus realising his "inner good side", или would he have remained a DE? I don't believe he would ever have gone to DD... the only reason he did was to try and save Lily, after all... But, I believe SOMEthing would have happened to make him realise the error of his ways. However, neither of those scenarios happened, so, we'll never know. And that's enough of my ramblings. In short... Is Snape bad? No. I hope that helps anyone who hasn't yet read the book, and doesn't mind spoilers. :)
|
|