Ответить на этот вопрос

Северус Снегг Вопрос

Could Severus Snape hold a relationship?

If not for his obsessive Любовь for Lily and all...
What would she be like?
How would he act to her?
If Ты dont think so, Why?
 MsEsmeBlack posted Больше года
next question »

Северус Снегг Ответы

frostydragon said:
Severus could еще than likely have and hold a relation but the conditions would have to be right.
1. go at his pace. If she jumped him like a rabid dog he'd run as far away as he could get.
2. She would have to be as much like him as different.
3. Be tolerant and patient.
4 Be able to maintain the relationship by herself for sometime until she gains his respect and trusts.
5.Since he is a very insecure person deep inside she would have to have his best interest at сердце and Показать him constantly.
6. Always be his friend first and lover second
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Good answer! :)
BlackHound posted Больше года
*
I like this anwer, esp the last one.:) I believe Severus is clever enough to realize what's the true cause that seperated him and Lily. He would begin a good relationship after Voldemort's death,when he was able to feel like his debt to Lily was paid.
forsnape posted Больше года
BlackHound said:
Yes, I believe Sev could hold a relationship, but he would really have to want it. Not everyone does. It would depend on a variety of variables.

I don't know what she *would* be like. I don't know *how* he would act to her. We really can't say we know either for sure; we can only speculate.

Incidentally, I don't believe his Любовь for Lily was obsessive at all; I think there was far еще guilt in it than 'obsession', and I think the longing had far еще to do with a desire to tell her that he was sorry for saying what he сказал(-а) that day, and to simply tell her that he had loved her. I do not believe, not for one moment, that Severus was deluded enough to believe that Lily might have one день loved him; their friendship ended in their 5th year, she began dating Potter their 7th year, and they married shortly after graduation. They were killed at 21. So that's five years that as far as we know, Lily and Severus did not speak. And considering the size of Hogwarts, and the fact there are approximately 1,000 students at the school at any дана time, that's not hard to imagine.

Why did he hang on so long? She was his first love. Quite a lot of people, или so I'm told, never stop loving their first love. No matter how much или deeply they Любовь their other partners, no one can ever replace that first person, no one can ever make them forget that very first person who made their сердце pound and pulse race. That first person who made them feel special. Like they mattered.

I have сказал(-а) this before, but the woman fortunate enough to have his full attention would have to be very special herself.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Guilt can do a lot of things to a person's psyche. Somewhere I think that Severus idealized what could have happened with her. He even idealized her, despite their falling apart. Death and absence can do that to people sometimes. Guilt is a powerful motivator - and I suspect Dumbledore to have used it to its full potency to tie Severus to his service.
LadyNottingham posted Больше года
bri-marie said:
Oh, I definitely think Severus could have had (and held)a relationship. But it would have to be after Voldemort was defeated, so that he could start to live his life for him and come to terms with what happened to Lily.

I think the girl would have to be:
1) Smart, someone he could relate to on an intelligence level.
2) Stubborn, hard-headed.
3)Understanding and patient - he's got a lot of scars and it's going to take a lot of time before he can Переместить past them.
4) Be open about herself and her intentions. Severus does not trust easily (nor do I picture him being very self confident), so he's constantly going to Вопрос about what she's really after.
5) Confident in what she wants. Severus is going to be looking for any excuse to push her away and any sign of insecurity of second-guesses from her is just going to make that worse, and make it easier for him to walk away.

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
thin66 said:
I believe Severus had a great capacity to love, even though he was never shown much Любовь as a child. It’s telling that the only person he loved was Lily although he did not know how to tell her. I believe he loved her from a child, from a time when he NEEDED to be loved and feel safe, she was the only witch he knew of his own age, so he was bound to feel a connection to her. When he went to Hogwarts he was with his own kind, but found it difficult to connect with the other students, probably because he had never known friendship или companionship, he was scruffy and never had the right clothes, so he clung to Lily who knew him, but she was in a different house. She was one of those ‘beautiful people” who find it SO easy to make friends. She left him behind.
When Lily died he was devastated, he became infatuated with the idea of what could have been, if he had done things differently, he believed Lily might have loved him one day.
I think if he’d have met the right woman, a patient, kind, intelligent and loving woman, a few years after Lily’s death, she may have healed him and shown what true Любовь is. After a hesitant start Severus would have realized that Lily was never for him, he would have still felt guilt about Lily’s death, but he would found how to Любовь and allow himself to be loved.

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
I like your answer, its very similar to what i was thinking.
MsEsmeBlack posted Больше года
*
I like your Комментарии on the relationship between Severus and Lily.
forsnape posted Больше года
SevSnapeForev said:
Oh, he definitely could've held a relationship. I think he would've looked for one after Voldemort was defeated if he was able to feel like his debt to Lily was paid and he could Переместить on. He would also want to feel like he was protecting someone.

She would have to be:
1. Inteligent, clever, and a skilled witch
2. Have a good sense of sarcastic humor
3. Ready to stand by his side through any situation
4. Quiet but able to have a conversation with him when the time was right
5. Forgive him for any past misdeeds, and Любовь him for the person he has become

He would care for her, be a wonderful husband. I don't believe he would be abusive like his father.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Why would she have to be a *skilled* witch? Why can't he have to teach her a little? That could certainly add some depth to the relationship, I think. ;) :-D <3
BlackHound posted Больше года
*
Even еще depth is if she is skilled its in arts he is not familar with and they learn from eachother. As a good relationship teaching and learning from one another.
frostydragon posted Больше года
*
BH, Ты put great ideas in my mind - and for once, not impure thoughts. I'm Письмо a fanfic where he meets a woman that is very different from him in her interests. I believe that people can learn from each other.
LadyNottingham posted Больше года
lilysev1134e said:
I think if he told Lily how he felt, then it have worked bettween hem. but i surpose things have to happen and maybe it was for the best anyway. If he did go out with her though i think that they would take it slow before it got serious between them. I also think Lily would have been the right person for him. She always protected him and looked out for him and was there always.
select as best answer
 I think if he told Lily how he felt, then it have worked bettween hem. but i surpose things have to happen and maybe it was for the best anyway. If he did go out with her though i think that they would take it slow before it got serious between them. I also think Lily would have been the right person for him. She always protected him and looked out for him and was there always.
posted Больше года 
next question »