That would be sooo cool!

just because it would throw everybody, not because i don't like her.

i think both would be ridiculous but if i had to choose i'd go minelli.

You know what I just was thinking? Minelli called Jane "Dorothy" once, in season 1. Dorothy had lost her family in the Wiz of Oz! At least, not forever, but she's searching for a way to go home so she can be with them. Jane is searching a way to kill Red John so he has peace with the loss of his family. Or am I really spending too much time on my homework?

I love VanPelt - she's smart, a lil broken and she's red too, it makes sense

Well, I can't imagine a little teenage Van Pelt running around slaughtering people. Minelli seems too nice but he'd be more likely.

Van Pelt is too young now that I think about it...but Minelli has a lot of evidence against him...and even though he quit he could show up one ep or so a season just to show he's still around or whatever, you know, popping in to say hi...

Neither of them!! I admit it, I thought about Minelli too, but I liked him too much XD

I kind of like Minelli now and I love Grace. the new boss is a real bitch to teresa and I love teresa's character. you can't fire her because jane screws up. jane always does that's part of the show!

How about one of Jane's past clients of his psychic business? The sick girl in the wheelchair?

sick girl in the wheelchair is dead by now, no question. her grandma lady probably is too. i liked minelli and van pelt is awesome. i hate hightower adn she's kinda on her way to being a mentalist too; she notices things, stuff like that. maybe she's red john and just hired the creepy guy to say he was? i don't know it's an idea. i would love for her to be red john, thogh, so we could get her off the show.

her name is madeline hightower

who is the sick girl in the wheelchair and her grandmother? I am lost. and who said they were red john. i have seen evvery episode and dont recall anything like that.

Her name is Madeleine but anyway she's a MF bitch!!!!

Definitely I don't think any of the Regulars should be Red John..it may be a surprise if it was but I think the regulars included Hightower are there and are there because they want Justice to prevail and regardless how one character acts...I think Red John should be someone Patrick knows at the least.