Сумерки (серия романов)

Ответить на этот вопрос

Сумерки (серия романов) Вопрос

Turning into a vampire meant sacrificing everything... (Read details)

If Ты haven't read Breaking Dawn, then I don't think Ты could really answer this Вопрос to its full potential...

Turning into a vampire meant sacrificing everything... Do Ты really think Bella sacrificed everything? I saw a Комментарий on Fanpop about Bella sacrificing her family and Друзья and human life. And that hit the debater in me. Think really hard. Did she really give up everything? Maybe her mortality, but if you've read Breaking Dawn, she was still able to see everyone she loved who was human.

Blaming Bella for choosing wrong, either for Edward или for becoming a vampire, is invalid. She never gave up anything! Just a heartbeat! Her decision for becoming a vampire, to be with Edward, Остаться в живых alot of it's weight, because of that fact. The phrase "it's the thought that counts" applies to this situation I think, but...

What do Ты think? Do Ты believe she gave up everything?
 mandapanda posted Больше года
next question »

Сумерки (серия романов) Ответы

katiecain said:
No, I don't think she did, but I think she SHOULD have. The whole point that made their Любовь еще 'special' was that she DID have to sacrifice things to be with Edward. And I still believe the argument that she should have stayed with Jacob as she could still live a normal, human life is relevant, because that's what Stephenie always said. She сказал(-а) Вампиры cannot have children, and Bella, as a newborn... Well, that was ridiculous.

However, she did still sacrifice things. Shye's still gonna have to stop seeing her family and friends, they're gonna realise she's not aging.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
LOL we've already touched on this when we PMd. She was intentionally going to sacrifice everything. She made her choice. She chose to be with Edward. She chose to sacrifice everything for him. Her humanity, her family, and friends. Stephenie, however, finished Bella's story that contradicted everything she has established in the Назад books. Being a vampire is a tragedy. Sacrificing so much, usually unwillingly. But, when Ты say, "still sacrifice things". In Breaking Dawn, Charlie knows something's up. I'm sure he would tell Renee. And the only friend that she would think about seeing again, was Angela. Let's face it, Bella didn't really fit in with the humans. Other than that, I don't see her ever seeing her "friends" at school. Idk, her choice, like I've сказал(-а) before, Остаться в живых all it's meaning when Stephenie wrote Breaking Dawn. And, again... it infuriates me! LOL
mandapanda posted Больше года
*
Agreed. To be honest, I find it impossible to Дебаты the Книги if the plot of BD is included. The characters, the dynamic, ideas are all so different to the other three that it's hard to consider them together.
katiecain posted Больше года
Hiding 5 comments... click to show.
*
After chapter 7 for me. Just bleh. I have no good feelings for that book. So I'll keep quiet. :)
mandapanda posted Больше года
Hellohoudini said:
I dont believe she really gave up anything....and as it was сказал(-а) by others and by Bella herself....it was like she was meant to be a vampire. She will always be young...she will always be beautiful...she has the Любовь of Edward forever....she has the daughter that she risked her life for... she still had her best friend...the Любовь of the Cullens...the Любовь of "most" of the wolves...she even got to keep Charlie and I believe in time she would have gotten Rene and Phil back.

I think what she did give up...her human life...pales in comparison to what she gained. And she's not clumsy anymore...total bonus! lol

Team Twilight
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
In the books, I don't recall Bella ever saying she was meant to be a vampire. She was meant to be with Edward, but not a vampire. I don't remember that at all. If Ты have the page number, I would gladly rethink my conclusion. But, I agree with the rest of what Ты said. "pales in comparison to what she gained"... she was supposed to lose everything for Edward. But BD ruined that image. :)
mandapanda posted Больше года
*
I dont have my copy of Breaking Dawn with me but its in there...after she changes,,,she says something about how she was glad to be a vampire that she had finally found her place in the world. And even though I Любовь Ты mandapanda...you know I'm gonna have to disagree with you...Breaking Dawn in my opinion was the best book in the series...but then I am a sucker for a happy ending. :)
Hellohoudini posted Больше года
*
haha I know where Ты stand when it comes to Breaking Dawn. :) no worries. It's okay if we disagree with that. Everyone either likes it and doesn't :) This just happens to be something we don't agree on :)
mandapanda posted Больше года
luvutoo said:
I dont think she gave up anything. Breaking Dawn is basically a book about Bella finally getting EVERYTHING she wanted and things she didnt know shed want. Even Stephenie confirmed this book was about the coming of Bella. She gets the man she wants, a baby of her own, something no other vampire could have, gets to keep Jake in her life, as well as hang out with the Волколаки with no repercussions, her dad knows her secret so he can always see her now, she has the perfect family, and shes rich. If thats sacrifice, i wish i could get it.
 select as best answer
posted Больше года 
next question »
Cookies help us bring you Fanpop. By using Fanpop, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn More Got It!