before they cast Ashley, I thought Rachel would be the bestt choice

but now I think ashley will do an amazinggg job

She's perfect for Alice but yeah I thought so too like hplotr91

Those two pictures look very similar to me...When I first saw them, I thought they were both the same person and I was thinking "Ok...and what is the point of putting the same person as both choices?!"

She is so cute... It's a petty they had to cut her hair. I liked it better like this.
I do know Alice has short hair though.

I love her nose. XD

if they shot the movie a couple of years ago, then Rachel would be better, if you consider the age. I believe Ashley will be a great Alice.

It dosnt matter on looks...it depends on who can actually get Alice and her whole personality spot on....and honestly I dont know if any of them can..(out of these two)....so Im a bit worried about that cause Alice is one of my favorite characters..so well just have to see what happens

I absolutely adore Ashley Greene. She is so spot on and she seems like she'll be perfect. I don't know Rachael Leigh Cook's acting...but I love Alice.

i loooove their choice on Alice :D

Well I chose Rachel because she is my fave, def beautiful! But I don't mind Ashley, I think she'll do just fine. :)

anyone but ashley