Brokenstar was a jerk. Is that even a question?

tigerstar was murderous but he was so awsome it was teribble he died.

I love Tigerstar. <:3
He didn't kill kits.

Brokenstar is definatly more evil people.

I like Tigerstar. He doesn't like Firestar and got a bit angry. Who can blame him? XD

I'd have to say Tigerstar...but both are about what and what but Tigerstar took it to an extreme level and thats what I like about him. *evil smirk*

tigerstar is evil brokenstar is just wack!!

i agree with u sister! :D

Brokenstar made kits apprentices at 3 moons, and warriors at 5 moons!! Imagine how many kits died while he was leader!
-----------------------------------------­---­---­---­-
As evil as Tigerstar was, he didn't kill kits. something tells me he liked kits. Tigerstar could have been a very noble leader if he followed the path of StarClan.

Tigerstar does try to kill leaders higher warriors and apprentices

Even Tigerstar didn't muder helpless kits.

GO TIGERSTAR!!!!

That was hard. Brokenstar murdered kits and had them training at 3 moons old and sent windclan into exile...Tigerstar tried to kill Bluestar and crippled Cinderpaw, brought Bloodclan to the forest and ended up getting killed, killed Stormfur :(, tried training Jaypaw and Brambleclaw to be evil. Now that is 1 evil cat.

Well, Yellowfang said herself that Brokenstar seemes spitful from the day he was born. Tigerstar, on the other hand, was actually okay until Thistleclaw started abusing him during training.

tigerstar was amboituous evil and selfish, brokenstar was only a threat for 1 book, tigerstar could be for like all the books! he meets with his kin and his "kin"

Okay so you know how Tigerstar killed Brindleface well i found a perfect song that fits Brindleface go to link
the begining of the song fits perfectly.

He killed Bluestar! I luved dat kitty! I also agree with bubbles4u22

Tigerstar tried 2 rule the whole forest!

If Brokenstar had lived there wouldn't be any more Warriors.

Tigerstar is kinda controlling brokenstar & heaps of other cats in the Dark Forest. so hes the ruler of all evilz.

i think that brokenstar is more evil because tigerstar murdered fully grown warriors and brokenstar killed helpless kits!and besides, tiger star treated his clan with royalty and brokenstar treated his clan like a pile of dung!

thts true

i would pick scourge if he was a option.

If it wasn't Thistleclaw abusing Tigerstar, Tigerstar wouldn't kill to get attention

agreed ^

Brokenstar killed Ferncloud in the last hope!

I agree with kikklin, it was Thistleclaw's fault Tigerstar went all bloodthirsty. Brokenstar is just a complete bitch. He made kits apprentices at 3 moons, he drove out WindClan, and he doesn't even care about the elders. Also he was killed by his own mother o.o

tigerstar was more eviler he killed brindle face so dogs could taste cat blood and lead rabbits to the thunderclan camp. he also killed stonefur for being half clan . he killed runningiwind, redtail (to be deputy). he lead scourge and blood clan to the forest . he also tried rule the forest. he killed swiftpaw with dogs injured brightheart really bad. he killed whitestorm by bring bloodclan into the forest . he kill bluestar by being dog pack . he also brought dark forest cats to fight starclan and the clans

Tigerstar's father became a kittypet so cats must have said mean things about him. And Thistleclaw was Tigerstar's mentor, and Thistleclaw is evil! Brokenstar never know has mather, but there is nothing more that would make him evil.

So be honest MY DAD!!

At least Tigerstar didn't send kits into battle...