Ответить на этот вопрос

Диснеевские принцессы Вопрос

What religions do Ты think the Дисней Princesses are?

 Shannaro101 posted Больше года
next question »

Диснеевские принцессы  Лучший ответ

minervadawn said:
The first three (Snow White, Cinderella, Aurora) are certainly Christian. At the time their Фильмы were made (30s to 60's) there was no other option. It was just expected, even if it wasn't specifically mentioned.

Ariel is tricky because the underwater kingdom and I believe Eric's human kingdom are fictional and there is no reference to any religion. The same goes for Repunzel.

Belle however lives in 1700s France which was predominately Catholic. The same goes for 1920's new Orleans and Tiana.

жасмин is Muslim as her father mentions Allah. However that is technically inaccurate as the movie seems to set in the era of the arabian nights, before the formation of Islam. So she should be worshiping the old pagan pantheon. On the other hand she appears to live in the Ta Mahal which wasn't built until the 1600's so let's just say she lives in a fictional Muslim country.

The last two are easy because they actually talk about their religion in the movie. Pocahontas believed in the law of nature (mother earth) and Мулан practiced traditional Chinese ancestor worship.

select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
*Best answer*
Mongoose09 posted Больше года
*
I agree
tiagih posted Больше года
*
Pocahontas becomes a Christian later.
sunnyfields posted Больше года
*
There were always other options- Judaism, atheism, agnosticism, или being pagan.
AudreyFreak posted Больше года
next question »

Ответы

ajotma said:
Snow White- Christian obviously
Cinderella- Christian
Aurora- Christian
Ariel- Christian
Belle- Christian
Jasmine- Muslim (lives in Arabian country)
Pocahontas- Native American Religion
Mulan- Traditional Chinese Religion (ancestor worship)
Tiana- Christian (she gets married in a church)
Rapunzel- Christian
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Arabia is not a country/town/anything
princesslullaby posted Больше года
*
Dude, she doesn't live in Arabia, just say an Arabian country.
CuteDiana posted Больше года
*
^Tiana is probably Pentecostal.
AudreyFreak posted Больше года
disneyprince said:
I see them all being Christian, with the exception of Ariel, Jasmine, Pocahontas, and Mulan. I don't see Ariel being Christian because of all the mythological aspects surrounding her and her family, along with the fact that Triton is linked to Greek mythology. жасмин is most likely Muslim because her father makes praises to Allah throughout the movie. It kind of annoys me that Дисней includes жасмин in the Рождество CDs and have her sing Рождество songs when she's obviously not Christian, at least they have the brains to give Мулан and Pocahontas songs about winter instead of Christmas.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Yeah, but Ariel probably became a Christian after marrying Eric I bet.
ajotma posted Больше года
*
Maybe жасмин is open-minded......
dee389 posted Больше года
*
Pocahontas did convert to Христианство in real life, so it actually would have made sense for her to sing Рождество songs.
sunnyfields posted Больше года
faya27 said:
Snow White-Christian
Cinderella-Christian
Aurora-Christian
Ariel-Pagan (worship greek gods like Poseidon) but became a Christian when she married Eric.
Belle-Christian
Jasmine-Muslim
Pocahontas-traditional Native American religion
Mulan-traditional Chinese religion (ancestor worship)
Tiana-Christian
Rapunzel-Christian
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
Same.
MrsEmmaPeel posted Больше года
yuchika said:
ok first off all those sayign she practices triditinol chinesse worship there is a better thing behind it

she practices taoism which is the art of nature
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
IsabelaDedel said:
Snow White-Christian(called on God in her movie?not sure,i haven't viewed the movie since I was 5)
Cinderella-Possibly Christian
Aurora-Possibly Christian
Ariel-believes in Greek Mythology,possibly converted to Christian when she married Prince Eric,but still it remains that her father is the son of Poseidon.
Belle-Possibly Christian
Jasmine-Islam(Muslim)
Pocahontas-believes in the law of nature but later on converts to Христианство in her movie's sequel where she also takes the Christian name Rebecca
Mulan-traditional Chinese religion(ancestor worship)
Tiana-Christian
Rapunzel-Possibly Christian
Merida-Possibly Christian
Anna and Elsa-Possibly Christian
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
AudreyFreak said:
Snow White, Cindy, Aurora- Christians (Catholics- at least, Snow and Aurora would doubtless be)
Ariel- whatever Русалки worship, then probably converted to Христианство after marrying Eric
Belle- Catholic
Jasmine- Muslim
Mulan- Ancestor worship/Taoism
Pocahontas- Shamanism
Tiana- Protestant
Rapunzel- Christian
Merida- likely a Pagan, it seems to be pre-Christianity Scotland but I could be wrong. She would probably be Protestant if it's sooner than I am thinking.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
ladystar10girl said:
Snow White- since the movie is based in 1500's Germany, she mostly like would be a protestant christian (lutheran to be exact since the reformation did take place in the 1500's and was started in Germany by Martin Luther.)

Cinderella- she could either be protestant или catholic since the original story is debated to be based in Germany или France.

Aurora- most likely catholic since the church had high power in Европа during her time in the medieval period.

Ariel- she could mostly likely be Greek based paganist but could of converted to anglican или catholic Христианство when she married Prince Eric.

Belle- since the movie is based in pre-revolutionary France, she would have had the catholic faith since it was a dominate christian denomination.

Pocahontas- she is originally native american, she mostly worship her Powhantan earth like religion, but she laters marries John Rolfe who is anglican/puritan in real life.

Jasmine- her story was based in early arabic times, where Ислам didn't come into existance yet. However there were paganism (Sumerian, Mesopotamian, etc.) & possibly Judaism in the region.

Mulan- Христианство and Ислам did not exist in ancient China during her time, there were many philosipical religions in China at that time. For example there was Daoism, Buddism, Conficism, etc.

Tiana- since the movie was based in the 1920's New Orleans. There was a mix of protestanism & catholicism in the region. Also, voodoo did exist as well.

Rapunzel- she is another character where her movie was based during the existance of protestanism. She dates back to the 1500's Germany, however, the movie seem to be based in the later period where there were conflicts between protestants and catholics in the region. I estimate her exact time period to between the time of the Spanish Inquisition & The Thirty Years War. She was either protestant или catholic when she was reunited with her parents.

Merida- again based in the medieval period. Depending on what region of Scotland или tribe she was from, she would either been a Germanic или Roman paganist или converted to catholicism depending what part of the medieval period she originated from.

Anna & Elsa - they are based in the late 1700's или Early 1800's (estimated to be during или in the middle of the Napoleanic Era) Norway. They would be part of the Anglican Church since some monarchy separated from the church earlier in the 1500's and 1600's to secure their line of the трон или to not let the Catholic Church influence their rule или their kingdom's religious freedom. Also, Anglicans had their own bishops. The trolls (and possibly Kristoff, since he is adopted by the trolls.) could of have knowledge или praticed Germanic paganism from the medieval period.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
nipun007 said:
Snow White - Christian (Protestant)
Золушка - Christian (Protestant или Catholic)
Aurora - Christian (Church of England) lives in England
Ariel - Christian (converted after marrying Eric)
Belle - Christian (Catholic)
жасмин - Muslim
Pocahontas - Native American Religion
Мулан - Traditional Chinese Religion
Tiana - Christian
Rapunzel - Christian (Protestant)
Merida - Pagan
Anna - Christian (Lutheran Protestant)
Elsa - Christian (Lutheran Protestant)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
The Church of England didn't exist in the 14th century, the time where Sleeping Beauty is set, so it follows Aurora must've been Catholic.
RoseRapunzel posted Больше года
angelortiz88021 said:
Cinderella, Belle and Snow White are in fact Christian because Золушка had faith that she would find Любовь and Belle showed the Beast who he was on the inside and Snow White prayed for God's blessing on the seven dwarfs.
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Spicy_Mimi said:
Well, Walt Дисней was actually a Christian himself.... So... I think most of them might be actually Christians или Catholics, because most royals are catholics. So I see it this way:

Cinderella: Catholic
Aurora: Catholic
Snow White: Catholic could be possibly Christian
Belle: Christian или maybe even Mormon (No mormon and catholicism is not christianity)
Tiana: She could be a Christian
Ariel: Greek Religion
Mulan: Buddhist cause of the temple
Rapunzel: She was kidnapped my a lady who was evil and was shielded all her life.... she probably doesn't have a religion. But if she was with her parents maybe catholic.

Jasmine: Muslim most likely cause of the Muslim temple and how she dressed.
Merida: Protestant
Elsa and Anna: Catholic/Protestant или Christians because of the message the story was actually sending.


Now these could be false, but these are just from my views.



select as best answer
posted Больше года 
sunnyfields said:
1. Snow White - Christian (she prays in the movie)
2. Золушка - Christian (gets married in a church)
3. Aurora - likely Catholic
4. Ariel - Polytheistic Greek religion of gods
5. Belle - likely Catholic
6. Pocahontas - converted to Christianity
7. жасмин - her father talks about God, but it is based before Islam, so maybe Judaism или some other god?
8. Мулан - Chinese Ancestor Veneration, which was a part of what is called the Chinese Traditional Religion according to what I researched
9. Tiana - likely Catholic
10. Rapunzel - Gothel probably didn't raise her to be religious but her parents were likely Catholic as since the 16th century, the Catholic Diet of Speyer in 1529 in Germany forced many protestant Christians to leave
11. Merida - Pagan
12. Anna and Elsa - Anglican (St. Olaf's Church is what inspired the church for Elsa's coronation, and it is Anglican)
select as best answer
posted Больше года 
Kadiekpop said:
*Snow White Christian
*Aurora Christian
*Cinderella Christian
*Ariel Greek Gods but when she fell
In Любовь with Eric she became
Christian
*Belle Christian
*Jasmine muslim became Christian
* Pocahontas Christian?
* Мулан ancestor worship
* Tiana Christian


select as best answer
posted Больше года 
*
How does жасмин become Christian?
PrincessAyeka12 posted Больше года
next question »