One word. Two syllables. Eight letters.

Broadway.

She was made for it. Puck... um... well, not so much.

I love Pucks/Marks voice but Rachel is my favorite singer in the glee club by far:)

rachel has a beautiful voice

Puck is awesome too though, they'd be my top two fave singers

I love puck's voice too though

I like puck better

Both have great voice but I love much more Puck voice =)

I would happily stand behind her with wet eyes while she sang solos <3

It seems like I have to keep saying it BROADWAY!!!! Puck/Mark has such a dreamy voice but Rachel is much more verstile, she can sing anything and its amazing even "Run Joey Run" lolz :)

oh yes, she's very versatile! Until BritneyBrittany I thought she could sing any song... This dream may have been destroyed but I still think she is the best performer on the show.

I love Mark's/Puck's voice too, but Rachel's/Lea's is just awesome! :)
But I do agree that the Britney one wasn't too great...

the best singers against each other? boohoo

Both are amazing, but i vote for Mark 'cause i want more Puck.

Rachel is sO good. Puck is too but Rachel has such a nice voice

ugh this was UNBELIEVABLY hard for me to choose because I love them both, but Mark's voice is probably my favorite on the cast. His just sounds a lot more natural to my ears while Lea's (while her voice is PHENOMENAL) sounds a bit forced and strained, especially as the seasons have passed. Just my opinion. Both amazing voices though.

Rachel's voice probably is better but personality I prefer Puck's