First of all, Harry Potter has suspense and is not entirely predictable. How many of Ты thought Quirrell was the bad guy in Philosopher's Stone instead of Snape? Not many, I think. How many of Ты thought Sirius Black was evil in Prisoner of Azkaban? A lot. Now that my point is made, I'll ask Ты this: how many of Ты knew Bella лебедь would choose Edward instead of Jacob? Possibly еще than a half of Ты if not ninety percent. Twilight is very predictable.
On that note, I'll say that Harry Potter has a very complex plot, spun together by interesting events unlike Twilight, where the only events are of Bella loving Edward and vise versa.
Next, I'll go onto the characters. Bella лебедь is the most horribly-written main character I've ever had the misfortune to come across. She is emotionally weak, male-dependent, selfish, and ridiculously popular. Harry is brave, righteous, loyal, caring and though he's the Boy Who Lived, JK Rowling didn't make everyone who knows him unrealistically Любовь him. Twilight's characters are one-dimensional while Harry Potter's characters possess both faults and good qualities. Take Wormtail for example; he's the most cowardly character described in the book, yet he had enough good in him to hesitate when he had Harry trapped. Now, Dumbledore; he's the wisest character in the story, full of kindness, and yet he'd mingled in the Dark Arts before. JK Rowling gave her characters strong characteristics and background stories, making them all the еще interesting. I don't see Stephenie Meyer doing that. She kept saying how Carlisle was compassionate but she never truly showed us, using his actions, how exactly he was compassionate, leaving us unable to imagine his compassion. She made Aro Volturi seem very friendly, yet the New Moon movie made Aro seem like a cunning vampire waiting for the right moment to pounce. As a result of the movie not matching the book, it only made Aro look like he has mental problems... poor guy.
What I want to talk about now is love. Stephenie Meyer's Книги are in the romance genre, meaning Любовь was supposed to be the books' main point... so why do I keep on getting the feeling JK Rowling managed to write a better Любовь story in a few chapters than Stephenie Meyer in a grand total of four books?
Let's see...exactly how many of Ты were deeply touched by Severus Snape and Lily's Любовь story? Many of you, I'm sure. Why? Perhaps because Severus' Любовь was unrequited and that he'd sacrificed everything for Lily. Ты Twilight Фаны will probably say: Hey, Edward would gladly sacrifice everything he owned for Bella and Bella would have done the same.
Okay, what I mean is that the Любовь between two characters (or if the Любовь is one-sided) has to seem realistic to make sure the reader is touched. Severus' Любовь is realistic, sure, but I don't think I can say the same for Twilight. Meyer had four Книги to make her readers shed tears at the intense Любовь between Edward and Bella. But did they? No. Of course, that's not her readers' fault; why should anyone shed tears at the sight of a few unrealistic words scattered across a piece of paper?
Oh, and did I mention too much Любовь and obviously not enough plot will make a book rubbish beyond words?
In conclusion, I'd just like to say that JK Rowling has a LOT of talent. And that Meyer will never match her in a thousand years. Of course, that may sound a little bitter. Fine, I'll phrase this again. I wish Stephenie Meyer, the best Автор ever born, the best of luck to be one quarter as good as JK Rowling.
On that note, I'll say that Harry Potter has a very complex plot, spun together by interesting events unlike Twilight, where the only events are of Bella loving Edward and vise versa.
Next, I'll go onto the characters. Bella лебедь is the most horribly-written main character I've ever had the misfortune to come across. She is emotionally weak, male-dependent, selfish, and ridiculously popular. Harry is brave, righteous, loyal, caring and though he's the Boy Who Lived, JK Rowling didn't make everyone who knows him unrealistically Любовь him. Twilight's characters are one-dimensional while Harry Potter's characters possess both faults and good qualities. Take Wormtail for example; he's the most cowardly character described in the book, yet he had enough good in him to hesitate when he had Harry trapped. Now, Dumbledore; he's the wisest character in the story, full of kindness, and yet he'd mingled in the Dark Arts before. JK Rowling gave her characters strong characteristics and background stories, making them all the еще interesting. I don't see Stephenie Meyer doing that. She kept saying how Carlisle was compassionate but she never truly showed us, using his actions, how exactly he was compassionate, leaving us unable to imagine his compassion. She made Aro Volturi seem very friendly, yet the New Moon movie made Aro seem like a cunning vampire waiting for the right moment to pounce. As a result of the movie not matching the book, it only made Aro look like he has mental problems... poor guy.
What I want to talk about now is love. Stephenie Meyer's Книги are in the romance genre, meaning Любовь was supposed to be the books' main point... so why do I keep on getting the feeling JK Rowling managed to write a better Любовь story in a few chapters than Stephenie Meyer in a grand total of four books?
Let's see...exactly how many of Ты were deeply touched by Severus Snape and Lily's Любовь story? Many of you, I'm sure. Why? Perhaps because Severus' Любовь was unrequited and that he'd sacrificed everything for Lily. Ты Twilight Фаны will probably say: Hey, Edward would gladly sacrifice everything he owned for Bella and Bella would have done the same.
Okay, what I mean is that the Любовь between two characters (or if the Любовь is one-sided) has to seem realistic to make sure the reader is touched. Severus' Любовь is realistic, sure, but I don't think I can say the same for Twilight. Meyer had four Книги to make her readers shed tears at the intense Любовь between Edward and Bella. But did they? No. Of course, that's not her readers' fault; why should anyone shed tears at the sight of a few unrealistic words scattered across a piece of paper?
Oh, and did I mention too much Любовь and obviously not enough plot will make a book rubbish beyond words?
In conclusion, I'd just like to say that JK Rowling has a LOT of talent. And that Meyer will never match her in a thousand years. Of course, that may sound a little bitter. Fine, I'll phrase this again. I wish Stephenie Meyer, the best Автор ever born, the best of luck to be one quarter as good as JK Rowling.
i persenally dont like ether series and heres why!!!
books
twilight
1) i am a reel vampire and i do not sparkl!!! stephanie shud have серовато-коричневый, dun, дун her reasearch before she wrote a book about vampires!!!
2) bella is a bad roll model!!!
4) edwerd is abusiv!!!
5) its unrealistic!!!
6) its badly writen!!!
7) edwerd is describd to much!!! it gets boring!!!
8) its boring overall!!!
harry potter
1) its not relatble!!!
2) its made for kids!!!
3)harry always beets te bad guy!!! he never looses!!!
4) harry gets away wit everything in skool!!!
5) they hav bad frends!!! ron leaves nd dosnt stay wit harry when peeps make fun of him!!!
6) its boring!!!
7) snape keeps his job even tho he bullys students nd is a deth eater!!!
8) dumbledoor doesnt reely care about harry!!! he leaves him at da durslys even tho they are abusiv!!!
movies
both Фильмы hav bad actors nd the filmers didnt follows the boks the way they were suposed to!!!
books
twilight
1) i am a reel vampire and i do not sparkl!!! stephanie shud have серовато-коричневый, dun, дун her reasearch before she wrote a book about vampires!!!
2) bella is a bad roll model!!!
4) edwerd is abusiv!!!
5) its unrealistic!!!
6) its badly writen!!!
7) edwerd is describd to much!!! it gets boring!!!
8) its boring overall!!!
harry potter
1) its not relatble!!!
2) its made for kids!!!
3)harry always beets te bad guy!!! he never looses!!!
4) harry gets away wit everything in skool!!!
5) they hav bad frends!!! ron leaves nd dosnt stay wit harry when peeps make fun of him!!!
6) its boring!!!
7) snape keeps his job even tho he bullys students nd is a deth eater!!!
8) dumbledoor doesnt reely care about harry!!! he leaves him at da durslys even tho they are abusiv!!!
movies
both Фильмы hav bad actors nd the filmers didnt follows the boks the way they were suposed to!!!