Гарри Поттер против Сумерек Article: My Personal Letter to Stephenie Meyer.

40

posted by ABDCFan-

Dear Stephenie Meyer,

May I first tell Ты that your 'Saga' is complete and utter crap. I also would like to highlight the fact that your 'books' are an insult to literature and vampires.
When Чтение them at first, I thought that they were quite good, and for a while I was a Twilight fan, but your fanbase has gotten huge, along with your head. This is one of the reasons I don't like Twilight. I've read other points on why Twilight and the rest of the 'saga' are bad, and I fully agree with the points raised. The points that I have read about have made me realise how bad Twilight and the rest of your Книги are, and I really can't believe I was a Фан of them. I've heard about your 'plan' to direct Breaking Dawn, and I would just like to say, that if Ты direct that movie, it won't be worth the money. I will refuse to watch it, and if forced to, I will go to sleep during it.
Your Книги have turned Фаны into violent people. Not all Twilight Фаны are violent, I understand, but alot are. I have read many cases on a Форум (I think it's called TwilightSucks) and they are all about how a Фан has reacted to someone when they've сказал(-а) that they don't like Twilight. I bet Ты don't even care do you? Some Twilighters have even made a cult. They treat the Twilight book like a Bible, and Ты like a God. Ты ARE NOT GOD.
I hope Ты know that half the population of the world hate или despise your Twilight books. Your Книги have made Друзья become enemies, but then they have also created friendships between the Haters of your books. There are people that I didn't even know before your books, and there are sites I didn't even know existed(Fanpop). If there's going to be one good thing that comes out of your 'Saga', it's going to be the friendships made between people that don't like your books. OH! And I'd just like to tell Ты that your book, The Host, is crap. It's confusing, boring, and I nearly fell asleep after Чтение the first chapter. It'son my bookshelf at the moment, and I don't know why, because it's absolutely sh*t. I'm seriously considering giving all your 'books' to a local library, или to my schools library. But I don't think I will. D'you want to know why? Because they'll make a good огонь in the winter, when I'm cold, and my parents refuse to turn on the heating to save money.
People are comparing your Книги to J.K.Rowlings', Anne Rices' and Bram Stokers'. This is wrong. Your Книги will never EVER be as good as theirs. Also, I heard Ты compared yourselves to one of them. Like, What the HECK is that about? Ты are noway NEAR as good as them. Big ego, much?
I know your early copy of 'Midnight Sun' was leaked onto the internet, and I saw that Ты сказал(-а) Ты might return to it in a few years time perhaps. Please don't. I read the start of it and was immediately bored.
To conclude this letter, I would just like to say that I will never be a Фан of your Книги ever again, and I am one of the many people that hate your books(you can probably tell). Please learn to downsize your ego, and not to write Книги based on dreams. Oh! And one еще thing, your Книги have made me fear Вампиры and werewolves/shapeshifters as much as I fear a stationary book. Hope Ты are well,
ABDCFan-

For Fanpoppers:
1. I'm sorry for the grammatical and spelling mistakes.
2.I'm not going to use my real name on the internet, as Ты can probably understand.
3. If you're a Twilight fan, don't have a go. This is MY opinion, and Ты will not change it unless Ты can put up a valid argument.
4. I know that some of it won't make any sense, so please don't be mean.
5. I hope Ты enjoy Чтение this, and maybe take ideas from it.
6. Please Comment, Become a Fan, and Save.
7. Thank Ты for taking the time to read this, and for commenting on it(if Ты commented) and for becoming a Фан of it(if Ты did) and saving(if Ты did).
8. I will try and thank Ты in the Комментарии section below, whether it be a good Комментарий или a bad comment.
Thanks again, and have a nice day! (:

simpleplan, ana27734 and 37 others like this

36 more comments

loading additional comments...

MrsRadcliffe ummm i love twilight but i absolutly adore HP more than twilight, i can't believe she thinks she could actualy be like JK ROWLING!!!!!!!!!! she doesn't even have the experience JK has!!!!.......................... i really like your letter but some parts i don't because i still sorta like twilight but not for edward and bella it's for renesmee and jacob

BB2010 you're my hero!!! here's what I gotta say about the JK Rowling and Meyer comparison: JK ROWLING > MEYER cuz Rowling actually learned to WRITE

luv_warriorcatz i dont really hate on the author just the book

PotterForever This has partially restored my faith in humanity! Great job, but be careful with this. You will be attacked if any twitards see it.

ABDCFan- Thanks everyone! :D @PotterForever -I know I may be attacked by Twihards, but I guess I'll cross that bridge when I get to it! Thanks again everyone :)

SnapeOWNSedward Snape approves.

cobragirl Sane person win.

xDark_Angelx Very nicely put. If you sent this, I'd love to see Meyer's face. ;)

PotterLambert93 I totally agree with you. This whole "saga" is complete crap! and thanks to this B****, my sister is completley brainwashed with this trash. Seriousley, you should send this to her and see what she says.

HPHedgehog You're the bomb dot com.(: I read this letter from some people who had questions about Twilight and sent it to Seth, SMeyer's brother, who is kind of her whipping boy. The letter was very well written and respectful. Seth insulted the letter and refused to send it to Meyer because it might hurt her delicate little feelings. When she was asked how she felt about people not liking her book, Meyer said that "they were the minority and they would get over it". This woman is absolutely full of herself, and I can't stand her.

TrueHufflepuff This is a very good letter! Have you considered sending it? It's a good idea, but don't, she won't ever read it. Oh, and also, some parts are too dramatical. Not the half of the population hates her. The half of the population are either poor people at poor countries the last thing to think is read teenage literature OR logical, sensible and mature beings that, desprite you and me, stay away from Twilight and the rest of the drama. (no offense to anyone, I am also a part of this not-logical, not-sensible, immature maze that spends its priceless time dissing Twilight.) Also, some parts are too quick; you should've emphathised more. But, in general, very good job, really enjoyable!

Ann_Longbottom I love it. :) I think there is violent fans for each fandom, though, cuz I seem to have a burning desire to cover Meyer in a gas/urine mix and set her on fire.

alexthedog ^Lol, that is so disgusting!

ABDCFan- ahahahaha! that is pretty disgusting. Wow. To everyone who has become a fan of this - Thank you so much! I'm glad that so many people share the same feelings as me towards Stephenie and her books. Again, just, thank you!

ladywyze To ABDCFan: I didn't agree with you, okay? Meyer's 'Midnight Sun' is AWESOME! Perfectly awesome, and much, much better than 'Twilight' itself. The leaked draft was so beautiful I can't believe it's not the original. Even if you do not love Twilight, you CAN'T deny it's fame. Love(the opposite), ladywyze Sick~

ABDCFan- Hahaha. It's cute because you think I care. If you didn't like it, why comment? I understand that you may like the books, but I don't. No, I can't deny it's fame, but I can deny that it's a good book. All stories whether they be short or long by Stephenie are awful. I'm sorry, but they are. Now, many people may or may not agree with me on that, but whatever. Please don't tell me that 'I don't know anything' or something along those lines, because for your information, I have read the whole Twilight Saga, as well as Midnight Sun, and that Life of Bree Tanner book thing. I liked them all at first, and now I hate them. Ok? Awesome.

Darkshine I'd take my hat off to you if I was wearing one. *applauds* You, madam, win at life.

ABDCFan- Why, thank you! :)

lunalovegood32 BWAHAHA!!!finally someone understands that life isn't about choosing to have a werewolf or a vampire as a boyfriend!The books are crap,and stephanie meyers nehttp://images.fanpop.com/images/emoticons/devil.jpgeds to get her head surgically SHRUNK.

ABDCFan- Hahaha, I guess so! I've just read back on this, and although I'm still kind of overwhelmed by the fact that people have commented and have been so nice to me. You guys are awesome. Don't forget it, ok? :)

hpfan8 I agree. Awesome letter. Too bad she can't read it

DramaQueen1020 Great article; you made excellent points! Good job! Hp is awe-some!

cunha27 Not a very good article at all. Sure you're entitled to your opinion but your article and the majority of the comments in here are simply mean spirited and nasty. I'm not going to try and change your mind as your opinions on Meyers books seem to be feelings based as oposed to anything factual. And like I said you're entiteled to them. It's obvious I disagree with your views. I'm just glad that there are enough people out there who do love Meyers books and send her enough fan mail and are willing to buy her books and watch the movies for her to continue producing them. I for one am very much looking forward to both the last Breaking Dawn movie as well as The Host coming out next year. There was a good thing that did come out of me reading this article though. It has given me the impetus to pen Mrs Meyers a thank you letter letting her know how much I've enjoyed her books and movies and to please ignore all hate mail and continue her good work

cassie-1-2-3 How disappointing. Even people who don't like Twilight should have recognized how ridiculous this article is. I'm SO glad Mr. Seth screens her emails, if this is the quality of "criticism" she gets.

FlameRose I also liked twilight before and I agree with you about that the twilight books aren't good, at all. And there's no way that twilight is (or ever will be) even close to HP. But what I don't really understand is why you hate The Host, it aren't a litterary masterpiece but it's not crap

12

Dracula

added by TeamSiriusBlack

Source: historiclols.cheezburger.com

12

Why Twilight is better than Harry Potter-The real reasons Ты asked for.

posted by KatyLautner

So, I stated my opinion on why Twilight is better than Harry Potter (there are so many haters on here!) and a lot of people wanted specific reasons, so here it is.

First of all, Twilight is about love. Real love. From what I understand, the "love" in Harry Potter isn't much. Edward would do anything for Bella. Die for her. How I see it, I know Ron and Hermionie get together, but he seems like a horrible person for her.

And while I was talking about Hermionie, here's something else. She's a week character. Unlike Bella, who struggles every day. Hermionie has no problems, the only things she has...

67

Why HP Фаны are annoyed by Twilight fans.

posted by smilesalot

Before Ты read anything: I happen to enjoy both HP AND T. I also happen to think HP is a billion times better. This is just my opinion. No need to freak out about this article. I am NOT trying to undermine T fans' opinions, I am just stating why I (and at least a few others) get annoyed with T fans.

So most of the posts on here have to do with of course, Harry Potter vs Twilight. But after skimming through comments, I found a shocking amount of crazy responses from twilight fans. This got me thinking. Maybe the reason this fued has grown so large is not because of the question: Is Harry Better,...