Okay, so...
1. Leyton Фаны seem to forget, that Brooke broke up with Lucas, not Lucas with Brooke. I mean they talk about true Любовь always, but if Lucas had always loved Peyton, he would broke up with Brooke to be with her, right? But we don´t know what would have happened if Brooke didn´t broke up with Lucas. Maybe they´d still be together.
2. okay then there quote "it´s you", well would be really romantic if he hadn´t сказал(-а) this a week before about Brooke. And who was there when all his dreams came true? And he wouldn´t went to Peyton if Brooke hadn´t told him to and earlier Skills.
3.Lucas wrote a book about Peyton, okay well he did but "Brooke is the other half", so...
4. Then he сказал(-а) "I do" to Lindsey, Leyton Фаны seem totally forget the fact that he would have married Lindsey.
5.Lucas never cheated on Peyton
Okay he didn´t but he kissed Brooke 24 hours after Peyton сказал(-а) "no" to his proporsal, the difference is that Brooke has self respect and pushed him away.
6. Leyton were meant to be from the begging
well...have LP Фаны ever watched season 2 and 3 I mean come on "I am the guy for you" "The difference is I Любовь Ты I wanna be with Ты not Peyton" and the damn destiny shot.
7. Lucas never loved Brooke, he always loved Peyton
Lucas spent almost the whole season 2 to want Brooke, who had a boyfriend and for SINGLEPeyton he called Jake i mean come on :-)
Well when Brooke сказал(-а) “I Любовь Ты to him”, he said” I Любовь Ты too”, to Peytons first “I Любовь you” his reaction was “oh”
8. It was Любовь of the first sight
Maybe for Lucas , but not for Peyton
9. Lucas always choose Peyton over Brooke
In the first season he picked Brooke over Peyton...at least first
In the third season he even сказал(-а) it " I wanna be with Ты Not peyton"
In the fourth season he defends Brooke to Peyton, because the sex tape...and he looked hurt when he watched it :-)
In the секунда season, Peyton and he never talked a lot, but for Brooke he did everything
10.Leyton is meant to be
No definetly not they only reason they got together is because chophia broke up.

Sorry for my bad English, I just really needed to say this.