First of all, Twilight is about love. Real love. From what I understand, the "love" in Harry Potter isn't much. Edward would do anything for Bella. Die for her. How I see it, I know Ron and Hermione get together, but he seems like a horrible person for her.
Lily sacrificed herself to save her son and because of that mark of Любовь she gave him the protection that stopped Voldemort from killing him. The whole point of Harry Potter is that Любовь is the strongest emotion ever. And yes, Ron can be a total жопа, попка towards Hermione, but he does Любовь her. In Deathly Hallows his Любовь for her nearly destroys him. He’s afraid Hermione prefers Harry over him and that fear turns against him.
And while I was talking about Hermione, here's something else. She's a weak character. Unlike Bella, who struggles every day. Hermione has no problems, the only things she has are self-created. She follows Harry into his troubles. Big whoop.
Hermione has flaws. She’s a muggleborn witch who has a very big need to prove herself to Показать she’s worth being on Hogwarts.(maybe it’s not literally been said, but I think she does) And she follows Harry into his troubles because they’re friends. That’s what Друзья do, they help Ты out. For better, for worse. In trouble Ты know your friends. If it were Bella she would’ve spend time with him because he’s famous, but as soon he’d be in trouble she’d dump him. And how exactly is Bella struggling every day? She gets a car for free! All the guys want her. She has no flaws. She’s smart. And Eddy Sparklepants obsesses over her. So how is she struggling???
And Harry, unlike Edward, drags everyone around him into his own problems. That's horrible for someone whose supposed to be the hero!
You’re not a hero when Ты can solve your problems alone. A hero is someone who, when confronted with danger, terror, can Показать bravery and is willing to sacrifice himself in order to save others and that is exactly what Harry did. And FYI, Harry is not the only hero.
And Voldemort, he's just violent! I hear a lot of people die, who wants to read about that? I mean, people die in Twilight, but come on, those are small things readers can handle. But Harry Potter? That's just depressing.
Of course he’s violent! He’s the bad guy. He’s not a sissy like Edward. He wants the ultimate power and he’s willing to go all the way to get that. And it’s very disturbing if Ты can handle death, even if it’s just one. I was affected by every death in Harry Potter.
The only good thing I find about Harry Potter is that Robert Pattinson plays Cedric. And I have no idea why he did that.
Because he likes Cedric, whereas he doesn’t like Edward.
Yes, well in Книги that are actually good, the good guys win! What kind of book is it if good guys die?
The good guys did win, but a war takes offers, from both good and bad sides. That’s what makes it realistic.
Twilight was also a bestselling novel, and has a bigger Фан base than Harry Potter
No, Twilight has a ‘louder’ Фан base of screaming Фан girls drooling over either Edward или Jacob whereas Harry Potter Фаны exist out of children, teenagers, adults, elder people, boys, girls. I’m not saying there are no boys liking Twilight или that only teenagers are into it, but the majority are screaming Фан girls.
Alright, reasons: if Harry Potter really is about love, why is everyone so happy to see death? It's sick! And Hermione even if she is teased about being a mud blood или whatever it’s called, she has a choice. She could quit Hogwarts или something. Bella has no choice, she is in love. And Harry is a fool, he always gets himself in trouble. Half his problems he created himself. And as with Voldemort, that war is not realistic! That never happens, at least not now. That's just horrible that someone would write about death as if it was an "okay thing". And also, Harry Potter is poorly written. There's always too much going on at one time.
We’re NOT happy to see death. We’re horrified by it. But again, that’s what war’s about. And J.K. Rowling gave her characters an actual personality with flaws and problems and feelings which makes it possible for us to be affected by their death.
About Hermione. Ты think she should quit Hogwarts because she’s being teased for being muggle born. Well, that would be pretty weak, don’t Ты think? She stands up for herself and is proud of who and what she is. She doesn’t run away for it because running away wouldn’t solve it. Should she quit her education because some morons call her mudblood? No! That’s what makes her a strong character. And Bella is not in love. She knew Edward for a week, had barely spoken to him and than decided she was ‘unconditionally and irrevocably in Любовь with him’ And Harry doesn’t get himself into trouble. Trouble finds him. He’s the chosen one. He has to stop Voldemort from taking over the world. And Ты want to talk about unrealistic war? In Twilight all the baddies die and the goodies survive. THAT’s unrealistic. Ты simply can’t have a war without good people dying или haven’t Ты been paying attention in history classes? Harry Potter is poorly written? There’s always too much going on at one time? Well, just because your little brain can only take so much doesn’t mean it’s poorly written.
All those actors are cheap. I'm so glad that most people have outgrown their Harry Potter obsession, and moved on to еще mature things.
I’m sorry, but did Ты just call the HP actors cheap? Ты do realize that includes Alan Rickman, Helena Bonham Carter, Maggie Smith, Gary Oldman, Robbie Coltrane, Rupert Grint… (I know Rupert is not yet so famous as the rest of the Список is but no one insults Rupert Grint in my presence) They are actually chosen for their talent, not for their looks. Kirsten always shows the same expression, how is that professional acting? And еще mature things? If by that Ты mean Twilight I think Ты need a vocabulary to look up the meaning of mature.
Well, as for Harry creating his own problems, in the 5th movie he went to the ministry and started a fight.
He thought his godfather Sirius Black was there, being tortured by Voldemort. He thought Voldemort was going to kill him, but it was a trick. He went there because he cares for Sirius and that’s what makes him human. And he had ‘dreams’ like those before. He also dreamt about Nagini attacking Mr. Weasly in the ministry and that was true. And that’s what made him think Sirius was really in the ministry.
]And wars do happen, just not overly violent ones like those.
Not overly violent??? Bombs, mustard-gas, the holocaust, torpedoes,… how is that not overly violent?
And if death is supposed to be presented as horrific, how come so many people die in Harry Potter?
BECAUSE IT’S A WAR (sorry for the Трофеи but Ты
simply don’t seem to understand what happens in a realistic war).
And as for Harry being a fool, his character is so unrealistic! He acts like he's the innocent one, he has problems too!
Sweetie, the fact he has problems makes him realistic!
And another thing, Harry kills Voldemort! What kind of story is it when the good guy kills someone for no reason! When Edward did kill a few people, he was protecting Bella. Harry had no reason!
No reason? Voldemort killed his entire family, killed half of the world (figure of speech of course), tortured the other half, put the whole world into darkness and tried to take control of it. Did Harry just have to let it be like that? Ты say you’ve read the first few books, but it seems Ты haven’t read them very carefully.
Why would she go to Hogwarts in the first place if she knew she had no magical ability and was going to be teased?
No magical ability??? She’s the smartest witch of her age! She saved Ron and Harry’s asses a bunch of times with her magic. Are Ты sure your read the book?
What I mean is the Cullens had reason for killing all those people. They took Bella in as part of the family, it was sweet.
The only reason they had was their stomach!
And I get that Voldemort killed a lot of people, but that still dosen't give Harry the right to go kill him. Killing is wrong, period. Unless it is self-defence, like in Twilight. The Harry Potter series fails to capture that.
Voldemort was taking over the world! It was either him или the world, moron! Ты fail to get the bigger picture!
And what else is disturbing is that Harry and Voldemort share thaughts, which makes Harry just as bad. I start to Вопрос who the bad guy really is.
They share thought because Voldemort gave him some of his powers on the night he tried to kill Harry. And Harry thought he was a bad guy, but as Dumbledore says, it’s our choices that Показать who we truly are, far еще than our abilities.
And no one has answered my question, WHAT IS AN EFFING PREPPY GURL? Is that some sort of insult to Twilight fans? And just because I have an opinion dosen't make me a joke!
I have no idea of what a preppy gurl is, but I’m pretty sure it’s not a compliment. And you’re a joke because your reasons are invalid! They’re making no sense whatsoever.
It's not Edwards fault he's in love!
He’s not in love. He’s just attracted by her smell.
Because I have yet to meet a Harry Potter Фан over the age of 10 that has a life. And I think Ты are the one on drugs, just like your precious Daniel Radcliffe
I’m 20 and I do have a life. And FYI Kirsten uses drugs, too, smart ass.
Also, Ты are a joke for thinking this childish Harry Potter crap compares to Twilight.
Okay, first Ты whine about the war being too violent and that there are too many people dying and now Ты call it childish? Ты do realize Ты are contradicting yourself here?
Wow, Ты are truly itiotic.
Ehm, the real idiot is he who can’t spell idiotic,…idiot!
No, Ты lose. Because I have stated my opinion, and Ты fail to respect it.
Your reasons are invalid. They’re stupid and not true.
The drug thing is overused. It's not funny little girl, you've already сказал(-а) it too many times.
It would be better if Ты were on drugs. That way saving might have been possible. Now I pretty much think you’re a hopeless case.
leave @specialemo alone, she is the only person who сказал(-а) anything worth listning to!
Just because we don’t say what Ты wanna hear, doesn’t mean it’s not worth listening to.
There Ты go
Lily sacrificed herself to save her son and because of that mark of Любовь she gave him the protection that stopped Voldemort from killing him. The whole point of Harry Potter is that Любовь is the strongest emotion ever. And yes, Ron can be a total жопа, попка towards Hermione, but he does Любовь her. In Deathly Hallows his Любовь for her nearly destroys him. He’s afraid Hermione prefers Harry over him and that fear turns against him.
And while I was talking about Hermione, here's something else. She's a weak character. Unlike Bella, who struggles every day. Hermione has no problems, the only things she has are self-created. She follows Harry into his troubles. Big whoop.
Hermione has flaws. She’s a muggleborn witch who has a very big need to prove herself to Показать she’s worth being on Hogwarts.(maybe it’s not literally been said, but I think she does) And she follows Harry into his troubles because they’re friends. That’s what Друзья do, they help Ты out. For better, for worse. In trouble Ты know your friends. If it were Bella she would’ve spend time with him because he’s famous, but as soon he’d be in trouble she’d dump him. And how exactly is Bella struggling every day? She gets a car for free! All the guys want her. She has no flaws. She’s smart. And Eddy Sparklepants obsesses over her. So how is she struggling???
And Harry, unlike Edward, drags everyone around him into his own problems. That's horrible for someone whose supposed to be the hero!
You’re not a hero when Ты can solve your problems alone. A hero is someone who, when confronted with danger, terror, can Показать bravery and is willing to sacrifice himself in order to save others and that is exactly what Harry did. And FYI, Harry is not the only hero.
And Voldemort, he's just violent! I hear a lot of people die, who wants to read about that? I mean, people die in Twilight, but come on, those are small things readers can handle. But Harry Potter? That's just depressing.
Of course he’s violent! He’s the bad guy. He’s not a sissy like Edward. He wants the ultimate power and he’s willing to go all the way to get that. And it’s very disturbing if Ты can handle death, even if it’s just one. I was affected by every death in Harry Potter.
The only good thing I find about Harry Potter is that Robert Pattinson plays Cedric. And I have no idea why he did that.
Because he likes Cedric, whereas he doesn’t like Edward.
Yes, well in Книги that are actually good, the good guys win! What kind of book is it if good guys die?
The good guys did win, but a war takes offers, from both good and bad sides. That’s what makes it realistic.
Twilight was also a bestselling novel, and has a bigger Фан base than Harry Potter
No, Twilight has a ‘louder’ Фан base of screaming Фан girls drooling over either Edward или Jacob whereas Harry Potter Фаны exist out of children, teenagers, adults, elder people, boys, girls. I’m not saying there are no boys liking Twilight или that only teenagers are into it, but the majority are screaming Фан girls.
Alright, reasons: if Harry Potter really is about love, why is everyone so happy to see death? It's sick! And Hermione even if she is teased about being a mud blood или whatever it’s called, she has a choice. She could quit Hogwarts или something. Bella has no choice, she is in love. And Harry is a fool, he always gets himself in trouble. Half his problems he created himself. And as with Voldemort, that war is not realistic! That never happens, at least not now. That's just horrible that someone would write about death as if it was an "okay thing". And also, Harry Potter is poorly written. There's always too much going on at one time.
We’re NOT happy to see death. We’re horrified by it. But again, that’s what war’s about. And J.K. Rowling gave her characters an actual personality with flaws and problems and feelings which makes it possible for us to be affected by their death.
About Hermione. Ты think she should quit Hogwarts because she’s being teased for being muggle born. Well, that would be pretty weak, don’t Ты think? She stands up for herself and is proud of who and what she is. She doesn’t run away for it because running away wouldn’t solve it. Should she quit her education because some morons call her mudblood? No! That’s what makes her a strong character. And Bella is not in love. She knew Edward for a week, had barely spoken to him and than decided she was ‘unconditionally and irrevocably in Любовь with him’ And Harry doesn’t get himself into trouble. Trouble finds him. He’s the chosen one. He has to stop Voldemort from taking over the world. And Ты want to talk about unrealistic war? In Twilight all the baddies die and the goodies survive. THAT’s unrealistic. Ты simply can’t have a war without good people dying или haven’t Ты been paying attention in history classes? Harry Potter is poorly written? There’s always too much going on at one time? Well, just because your little brain can only take so much doesn’t mean it’s poorly written.
All those actors are cheap. I'm so glad that most people have outgrown their Harry Potter obsession, and moved on to еще mature things.
I’m sorry, but did Ты just call the HP actors cheap? Ты do realize that includes Alan Rickman, Helena Bonham Carter, Maggie Smith, Gary Oldman, Robbie Coltrane, Rupert Grint… (I know Rupert is not yet so famous as the rest of the Список is but no one insults Rupert Grint in my presence) They are actually chosen for their talent, not for their looks. Kirsten always shows the same expression, how is that professional acting? And еще mature things? If by that Ты mean Twilight I think Ты need a vocabulary to look up the meaning of mature.
Well, as for Harry creating his own problems, in the 5th movie he went to the ministry and started a fight.
He thought his godfather Sirius Black was there, being tortured by Voldemort. He thought Voldemort was going to kill him, but it was a trick. He went there because he cares for Sirius and that’s what makes him human. And he had ‘dreams’ like those before. He also dreamt about Nagini attacking Mr. Weasly in the ministry and that was true. And that’s what made him think Sirius was really in the ministry.
]And wars do happen, just not overly violent ones like those.
Not overly violent??? Bombs, mustard-gas, the holocaust, torpedoes,… how is that not overly violent?
And if death is supposed to be presented as horrific, how come so many people die in Harry Potter?
BECAUSE IT’S A WAR (sorry for the Трофеи but Ты
simply don’t seem to understand what happens in a realistic war).
And as for Harry being a fool, his character is so unrealistic! He acts like he's the innocent one, he has problems too!
Sweetie, the fact he has problems makes him realistic!
And another thing, Harry kills Voldemort! What kind of story is it when the good guy kills someone for no reason! When Edward did kill a few people, he was protecting Bella. Harry had no reason!
No reason? Voldemort killed his entire family, killed half of the world (figure of speech of course), tortured the other half, put the whole world into darkness and tried to take control of it. Did Harry just have to let it be like that? Ты say you’ve read the first few books, but it seems Ты haven’t read them very carefully.
Why would she go to Hogwarts in the first place if she knew she had no magical ability and was going to be teased?
No magical ability??? She’s the smartest witch of her age! She saved Ron and Harry’s asses a bunch of times with her magic. Are Ты sure your read the book?
What I mean is the Cullens had reason for killing all those people. They took Bella in as part of the family, it was sweet.
The only reason they had was their stomach!
And I get that Voldemort killed a lot of people, but that still dosen't give Harry the right to go kill him. Killing is wrong, period. Unless it is self-defence, like in Twilight. The Harry Potter series fails to capture that.
Voldemort was taking over the world! It was either him или the world, moron! Ты fail to get the bigger picture!
And what else is disturbing is that Harry and Voldemort share thaughts, which makes Harry just as bad. I start to Вопрос who the bad guy really is.
They share thought because Voldemort gave him some of his powers on the night he tried to kill Harry. And Harry thought he was a bad guy, but as Dumbledore says, it’s our choices that Показать who we truly are, far еще than our abilities.
And no one has answered my question, WHAT IS AN EFFING PREPPY GURL? Is that some sort of insult to Twilight fans? And just because I have an opinion dosen't make me a joke!
I have no idea of what a preppy gurl is, but I’m pretty sure it’s not a compliment. And you’re a joke because your reasons are invalid! They’re making no sense whatsoever.
It's not Edwards fault he's in love!
He’s not in love. He’s just attracted by her smell.
Because I have yet to meet a Harry Potter Фан over the age of 10 that has a life. And I think Ты are the one on drugs, just like your precious Daniel Radcliffe
I’m 20 and I do have a life. And FYI Kirsten uses drugs, too, smart ass.
Also, Ты are a joke for thinking this childish Harry Potter crap compares to Twilight.
Okay, first Ты whine about the war being too violent and that there are too many people dying and now Ты call it childish? Ты do realize Ты are contradicting yourself here?
Wow, Ты are truly itiotic.
Ehm, the real idiot is he who can’t spell idiotic,…idiot!
No, Ты lose. Because I have stated my opinion, and Ты fail to respect it.
Your reasons are invalid. They’re stupid and not true.
The drug thing is overused. It's not funny little girl, you've already сказал(-а) it too many times.
It would be better if Ты were on drugs. That way saving might have been possible. Now I pretty much think you’re a hopeless case.
leave @specialemo alone, she is the only person who сказал(-а) anything worth listning to!
Just because we don’t say what Ты wanna hear, doesn’t mean it’s not worth listening to.
There Ты go
